Products · By 6xrpse · 5 min read · Updated 10 Nov 2026
Cash-Settled Options, Explained
A cash-settled option never delivers shares. When it is exercised, the only thing that changes hands is cash equal to the option's intrinsic value at settlement. This guide explains how that cash amount is calculated, when it is paid, and the details that catch new traders out.
What a cash-settled option is
Most options on individual stocks and ETFs are physically settled. If you exercise a standard equity call, you buy 100 shares at the strike price. If you are assigned on a short put, you buy 100 shares. The shares themselves move between accounts.
A cash-settled option skips the shares entirely. On exercise, the holder receives a cash payment and the writer pays it. The payment equals how far the option is in the money at the settlement value, multiplied by the contract multiplier.
The most common cash-settled options in the US are index options, such as options on the S&P 500 index (SPX), the Mini-SPX index (XSP), the Nasdaq-100 index (NDX), the Russell 2000 index (RUT) and the Cboe Volatility Index (VIX).
Why index options settle in cash
An index is a calculation, not something you can hold. Delivering the S&P 500 would mean delivering every stock in the index in its exact weight, which is impractical for both sides of the trade.
The Options Industry Council describes index options as designed to capture the performance of the broad market. Cash settlement achieves that directly: the payout tracks the index level without anyone needing to buy or sell hundreds of stocks.
How the cash amount is calculated
Three inputs decide the payout: the exercise settlement value (the official index figure used for settlement), the strike price, and the contract multiplier. For most US index options the multiplier is 100, meaning each index point is worth $100 per contract. Always check the contract specifications, because some products use a different multiplier.
For a call, the cash amount is the settlement value minus the strike, times the multiplier. For a put, it is the strike minus the settlement value, times the multiplier. If the result is zero or negative, the option has no intrinsic value and expires worthless.
Hypothetical example: an index has an exercise settlement value of 5,000 and the multiplier is 100. A 4,950 call is worth (5,000 - 4,950) x 100 = $5,000 to the holder, and the writer pays $5,000. A 5,050 put is worth (5,050 - 5,000) x 100 = $5,000. A 5,000 call, a 5,000 put, a 5,050 call and a 4,950 put all expire worthless.
Remember that the cash amount is not your profit or loss. Your result also depends on the premium you paid or received when you opened the position.
- Call cash amount = (settlement value - strike) x multiplier, if positive
- Put cash amount = (strike - settlement value) x multiplier, if positive
- The holder receives the amount; the assigned writer pays it
- Cash generally settles on the next business day after exercise
AM settlement vs PM settlement
Not every cash-settled option settles on the same price. This is the detail that most often surprises newer traders.
PM-settled options use the index value based on closing prices on expiration day. SPXW options (the weekly and daily SPX series) work this way and normally stop trading at 4:00 p.m. ET on expiration day, per Cboe.
AM-settled options use a Special Opening Quotation, or SOQ. Standard monthly SPX options are AM-settled: they ordinarily stop trading the business day before expiration (usually a Thursday), and the settlement value is calculated the next morning from the official opening price of every stock in the index.
Cboe notes that the SOQ is not calculated until every component has opened, so it is not tied to a specific time of day and will usually differ from the index value you see on screen at the open. In practice, an AM-settled option's final value is decided after you can no longer trade it. Overnight news can move the settlement value away from Thursday's close, in either direction.
Exercise style and assignment
Settlement method and exercise style are separate ideas. Cash settlement describes what changes hands. Exercise style describes when exercise can happen. SPX, XSP and NDX options are European-style and can only be exercised at expiration, so a writer cannot be assigned early. Some older cash-settled products, such as OEX options, are American-style and can be exercised any time before expiration.
At expiration, OCC uses exercise by exception. Once the exchange provides the settlement value, in-the-money options are exercised automatically unless the holder's broker submits instructions otherwise. There is no stock position to manage afterwards: the account is simply credited or debited the cash amount.
Practical differences for retail traders
Because no shares arrive, cash settlement removes the classic surprise of waking up long or short hundreds of shares after expiration. It also removes the need to have enough capital to take delivery.
It does not remove risk. A short cash-settled option that finishes in the money still requires you to pay the full cash amount, and on an index with a $100 multiplier that amount can be large. For AM-settled series, you also carry the overnight gap between the last trading session and the opening settlement.
Contract size matters too. One SPX contract controls roughly ten times the notional value of one SPY contract, while XSP is one tenth the size of SPX. Knowing the multiplier and index level tells you the notional exposure of every contract before you place an order.
Taxes can differ as well. Under US rules, many broad-based index options are treated as section 1256 contracts, which have their own reporting rules, while options on ETFs and individual stocks generally are not. IRS Publication 550 covers the details; confirm your own situation with a tax professional.
The Short Version
- A cash-settled option pays its intrinsic value in cash; no shares change hands.
- Payout = in-the-money amount at the exercise settlement value x the contract multiplier.
- PM-settled series use closing prices; AM-settled series use an opening quotation calculated after trading has stopped.
- Cash settlement is about what changes hands; European or American style is about when exercise can happen.
- No shares arrive, but a short in-the-money position still owes the full cash amount.
Questions
Are SPY options cash-settled?
No. SPY is an ETF, so its options are physically settled in shares. SPX options on the S&P 500 index are cash-settled.
When do I receive the cash from an exercised index option?
Settlement and the transfer of cash generally happen on the next business day after exercise. Your broker may show the credit or debit at slightly different times.
What is the exercise settlement value?
It is the official index figure used to calculate how much cash changes hands on exercise. For PM-settled options it comes from closing prices; for AM-settled options it is a Special Opening Quotation built from each component's opening price.
Can I be assigned early on a cash-settled option?
Only if it is American-style. European-style index options such as SPX, XSP and NDX can be exercised only at expiration, so early assignment cannot happen.
Why did my AM-settled option settle at a different level than Thursday's close?
AM-settled options stop trading the day before expiration, and the settlement value is calculated from the next morning's opening prices. Any overnight move is reflected in that value.
Do cash-settled options still need to be closed before expiration?
They do not have to be. In-the-money options are exercised automatically for cash. Some traders close positions beforehand to avoid settlement uncertainty, particularly on AM-settled series.
Sources
- Options Industry Council: Cash Is King, Why Some Options Never Deliver Shares
- Cboe: Special Opening Quotation Settlement of A.M.-Settled Index Futures and Options
- Cboe: SPX and SPXW Options Specifications
- OCC: Options 101, Index Options Primer
- IRS Publication 550: Investment Income and Expenses
This article is for educational purposes only and is not financial, investment, or tax advice. Options involve substantial risk and are not suitable for all investors. All examples are hypothetical.
